Monday, November 26, 2007

A Sinking in Antarctica. The Hysteria Begins


Photo credit: TV3

As you probably know, the Explorer sank off the coast of Antarctica recently.

The big news, the really important news, is that no one died. All aboard were evacuated safely in what seems to have been an orderly and professional manner.

That hasn't stopped the hand wringing about tourism in Antarctica. Expect more of this in the near term.

I certainly don't want to minimize the damage that a sunken vessel filled with diesel might cause to the ecosystem, but if this is the first sinking in some 40 years of sharing the wonders of earth's last true frontier with those willing and able to pay the fare, then it seems to me the cost/benefit ratio here has been amply demonstrated.

And danger isn't unique to Antarctica. A cruise ship sank just this year in the placid waters of Santorini. Is anyone talking about "misgivings" on Aegean tourism?

As home-based travel agents, I think we should be aware of a number of things:

** Demand for the Antarctic will decline in the short term. Then, inevitably, it will rise again.
** Because of that, expect to see more "special offers" from operators to the region.
** Which in turn will open up new selling opportunities for you to reach out to your more adventurous clients, perhaps those who have balked at Antarctica because of cost.
** Choose suppliers wisely. The Explorer was a nearly 40-year old ship operated by an "off-brand" Canadian operator.
** Make sure the supplier has done everything humanly possible to assure safety and sell that safety to your clients.
** And just in case, sell travel insurance. Medevac insurance might have come in handy to some of the evacuees, although I gather that injuries were minor. "Stress" was the big complaint. Heck, I can get that at home!

I think it's also fair to say that, once the "stress" fades away, the passengers on the ill-fated Explorer's last voyage will look back on the experience as one of the most exciting of their years of travel and will bask in the spotlight they will be accorded when they recount their tale at cocktail parties for years to come. In fact, I sorta wish I'd been aboard.

Labels: , , ,

3 Comments:

Anonymous David said...

A 40 year old ship ship that sinks from a "fist sized" hole was a menace and disaster waiting to happen... a symbol of the GREED of the owners and operators who allowed this antiquated wreck to even exist. This travel firm ought to be put out of existence

9:24 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am currently working in Antarctica and I can certainly see the alure to all.

However your "cost/benefit" seems a little lopsided. Your benefits far outway any small issues like the pristine environment that you are trying to promote.

Any environmental disaster like a large ship sinking is disasterous, but for a truely almost unspoilt environment, it will ruin the one thing you are trying to promote.

Yes thats right, lets just go, oh well, these things happen from time to time but lets make the most of it, sell it before it gets ruined and then we can move onto raping the next pristine environ... oops there isn't one left.

10:23 AM  
Blogger Kelly Monaghan said...

And yet . . .

I find it interesting that you apparently exempt yourself here. It's okay for you to work in Antarctica (which presumably means a long-term presence, complete with waste disposal challenges) but not okay for the great unwashed to visit briefly, hopefully taking nothing but photos and leaving nothing but footprints (as the saying goes).

I'm sympathetic to your overall point, though. Yes, we seem to be destroying the planet. But expecting humans to simply forget about vast swaths of the planet and never go there is simply pollyanna-ish.

The same argument could be used against any tourism or travel. Just listen to a New Yorker rail against the tourist hordes! And there's no doubt that the Big Apple would be a very different fruit without them.

Saying that tourism to Antarctica should stop may make sense in some ultimate sense, but it simply won't happen. Better to put our heads together and find the best way to manage it for the benefit of all.

11:12 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home